The mannered approach to composition of innumerable composers of the
18th century is a close shave from the three here -- Franz Krommer,
Johann Baptist Vanhal, and Antonio Rosetti. Fortunately they have a touch
more sparkle than some. Bruno Meier's flute floats their solo lines
most agreeably [listen -- track 1, 2:02-3:02].
Nonetheless, you need to accept a measure of conventional figuration from
all three which breaks out of standard patterning every so often. It has
always seemed perverse to me that composers of whatever period who fall
back on routine decoration are giving posterity a sure sign of weakness,
and therefore an 'own goal' signal. Much of the pleasure here
is for the performers' attentive and polished playing.
Copyright © 30 May 2001
Basil Ramsey, Eastwood, Essex, UK
CD INFORMATION - KOCH/SCHWANN 3-1228-2
PURCHASE THIS DISC FROM CROTCHET
<< Music
& Vision home Recent reviews
Charles Wood >>
Record Box is Music & Vision's regular Wednesday series
of shorter CD reviews
|