<< -- 3 -- Roderic Dunnett RESPLENDENT PANOPLY
In Amneris' aria, with crossed Pharaonic insignia, Busuioc was as magnificent
as she was terrifying; the bassoon accompanying Ghioalda's subsequent Aida
aria underlined the quality of all the Chisinau wind section (the strings,
perhaps overworked night after night, are less predictable : they alternate
between brilliant and moodily, almost idly drab). The staging for Radames's
return -- with massed wind and brass, plus ballet -- was terrific, despite
some backstage noise for Aida's preceding recitative.
Yet nothing prepared one for the devastating appearance of Amonasro :
gaunt, haggard, massive, a towering presence, whose monumental righteousness
and forlorn stolen dignity swept all before it. This was Boris Materinco,
one of the great voices, surely, to emerge from the debris of the former
Soviet Union : a voice and stage authority to set beside Ghiaurov and the
great Boris Christoff. The pizzicato violas that (as often elsewhere)
encapsulate oriental -- or in this case, Ethiopian -- poignancy and tragedy
were remarkably effective for his great appeal. So too was the ensuing instrumental
detail : massive trombone beneath the tutti, as the chorus chimed
in with the soloists; low flutes and violas -- an almost Puccinian sound
-- and then attractively reedy oboe solo heralding Aida's aria; the woodwind
exchanges as she plans escape; the beautifully phrased clarinet that accompanies
Amneris; or the basses and cellos that feed in the unison lament -- all playing
of a high order.
There was the ocasional further drawback : an element of separation between
priest and orchestra (made up for by his awesome, spot-on next aria); the
odd untidy string passages scattered here rather too liberally, culminating
in an unforgivably weak final cadencing, as if the violin desks were already
wiping their bows and packing their bags. But this was a powerful evening,
and an Aida as stupendous as their Madam Butterfly was melting.
Copyright © 4 February 2001
Roderic Dunnett, Coventry, UK
<< Music
& Vision home
Pelléas et Mélisande >>
|