The serious rival
PATRIC STANDFORD examines music
appealing to the listener with more time and patience
In the late 1940s, Alan Rawsthorne seriously rivalled Britten among critics
and commentators anxious to put a name to the major voice in post-war British
music. Yet within a decade most had agreed that Britten's far more simple
melodic lines and clearly audible technical operations made huge popular
gains over Rawsthorne's more austere musical language which appeals to the
listener with more time and patience, the listener who is a musician whose
well informed interest would follow through the musical discussion. Rawsthorne
is more like a late Beethoven than a late Haydn; his work demands and rewards
the greater effort of concentration. Not all its skill and craftsmanship
are evident immediately, and yet the listener is aware that these qualities
exist. It is not the kind of complexity all too often used to hide mediocrity
and poverty - though we hear enough evidence now of naivety being used to
disguise the same deficiencies! Rawsthorne is a fine artisan driven by a
glow of inspired invention and the desire to communicate music of real worth.
It is therefore appropriate that alongside their new recordings of his string
orchestral music and the two Violin Concertos, Naxos should be issuing one
of the two recent CDs of his chamber music - music through which he most
carefully and intimately puts his craft to work, and pieces that need to
be heard at leisure, several times. The Naxos recital consists of string
chamber music. It covers a time span of about 30 years, from the Concertante
for violin and piano of 1935, played by Nadia Myerscough [listen
to its plaintive and magical opening - Naxos 8.554352 track 5, 00:59-01:38]
and the Viola Sonata (Martin Outram) written a little later, to the Piano
Trio (1962) and the Piano Quintet, one of Rawsthorne's last pieces (he died
in 1971 aged 66) and commissioned by Cardiff University's Music Department.
The Quintet's first performance was given by the University Ensemble, with
which John McCabe was then pianist, and he no doubt revives fond musical
memories in performing it again for this recording. At this late stage,
Rawsthorne's harmony had become more tonally evasive, though behind this
chromatic camouflage is a musician always with a singular focal point in
his musical ear. [Listen - Naxos
8.554352 track 4, 00:25-01:16.] Between these
pieces, chronologically, is the Cello Sonata, written in 1950 and played
by Peter Adams, sensitively accompanied (as are the other solo pieces) by
Yoshiko Endo.
Continue >>
Copyright © 20 February 2000 Patric
Standford, Wakefield, UK
|
To listen to the aural illustrations in this review,
you may need to download RealNetworks' realplayer G2. |
<< Music &
Vision homepage Songs
of Edward Elgar >>
|